HMDA Denial Rate
Rising denial rates mean lenders are tightening — that's a leading read on how hard your next refi exit is going to be, and how much buyer demand evaporates before the Fed's rate move shows up in Redfin's weekly price feed. Versus FL + US: when Hillsborough denials climb faster than the state, local underwriting is reacting to something specific (insurance loss, condo assessments, migration reversal).
- source
- HMDA
- frequency
- annual
- units
- percent
- geo
- Hillsborough County, Florida
Note: Denial rate = count(action_taken=3) / sum(count where action_taken in {1,2,3,4,5}). Action codes — 1: originated, 2: approved not accepted, 3: denied, 4: withdrawn, 5: closed for incompleteness. Excludes 6 (purchased — already counted as origination by the originating lender) and 7/8 (preapproval requests — different funnel). Standard HMDA convention. Fetch loops 2018–2024.
Denial rate sits at 20.18%, down 1.92 percentage points from a year ago—the first meaningful compression after three straight years of tightening. Hillsborough is tracking below Florida's 21.06% but running 2.37 points hotter than the national 17.81%, which suggests local lenders are still pickier than the median US underwriter even as they've loosened from 2024's peak. The inflection matters: if denials keep rolling over, refi windows open up and marginal buyers start showing up in purchase comps again. Watch whether Florida's line follows Hillsborough down or holds—if the state stays tight while the county relaxes, something local shifted (insurance appetite returning, condo board resets taking effect, or just seasonal variance in the application mix).
"""
HMDA Denial Rate — Hillsborough County, FL, annual % of apps denied.
Denial rate = count(action=3) / sum(count where action in {1,2,3,4,5}).
"""
import requests
YEAR = 2024
url = (
"https://ffiec.cfpb.gov/v2/data-browser-api/view/aggregations"
f"?years={YEAR}&counties=12057&actions_taken=1,2,3,4,5"
)
response = requests.get(url, timeout=30)
response.raise_for_status()
buckets = {row["actions_taken"]: row["count"] for row in response.json()["aggregations"]}
denied = buckets.get("3", 0)
total = sum(buckets.values())
rate = 100 * denied / total if total else 0.0
print(f"{YEAR} Hillsborough denial rate: {rate:.1f}% ({denied:,} of {total:,})")
You are analyzing HMDA dataset hmda_denial_rate — HMDA Mortgage Application Denial Rate (annual %). Context: Rising denial rates mean lenders are tightening — that's a leading read on how hard your next refi exit is going to be, and how much buyer demand evaporates before the Fed's rate move shows up in Redfin's weekly price feed. Versus FL + US: when Hillsborough denials climb faster than the state, local underwriting is reacting to something specific (insurance loss, condo assessments, migration reversal). Attributes - Units: percent - Frequency: annual - Source: HMDA · Hillsborough County, Florida Latest observation: 20.18% as of 2025-12-31 Year-over-year change: -8.69% Analyze this metric for a tech-forward real estate investor with 1–3 properties. What is it signaling right now? What should I watch next?